PayPal transaction filter + payments mapping + external-id dedupe were
inline and untested, and auth was a hand-rolled select instead of the
shared helper. Extracted to pure lib/paypal-logic.ts (also fixes a
latent throw on a missing/invalid PayPal date by falling back to now);
route now uses requireMemberWithRole. 7 tests; suite 521. Behavior
otherwise unchanged.
The webhook's money/status mapping (Basil field relocations, period
extraction, customer-id unwrap, status patch, invoice->payment row,
minor->major) lived inline in the route with zero test coverage - the
biggest untested critical path in the codebase. Extracted to a pure,
SDK-free lib/stripe/webhook-logic.ts (structural input types) and
refactored the route to only do signature verify + network + DB writes.
12 new tests cover the Basil edges and link/unlink + defaults. Behavior
unchanged; suite 514.
PayPal client_secret (and any secret-named integration field) was stored
plaintext in integrations.config, unlike Stripe/door which use the
AES-256-GCM vault. A DB read or backup leaked it in cleartext.
- lib/secrets/vault.ts: canonical generic storeSecret/readSecret +
isSecretConfigField (the proven Stripe vault logic, generalized).
- saveIntegration: secret-named fields go to the vault, only a *_ref is
kept in config; blank submit preserves the ref (write-only like
Stripe); legacy plaintext auto-migrates into the vault on next save.
- paypal/sync reads client_secret from the vault, transitional fallback
to legacy plaintext until the next save.
- Docs updated (API_REFERENCE, ARCHITECTURE 10.3). 502 tests.
Independent audit verdict was NOT SAFE; all findings fixed:
- dispatcher Idempotency-Key is now per-attempt (${id}:${attempts}),
not row id alone, so a transient-failure response cached by Resend
cannot permanently suppress every retry and silently lose an email.
- enqueueDues is fully try/catch wrapped so a notifications-table or
render failure can never throw into / wedge the Stripe money path.
- dues_lapsed dedupe falls back to the subscription id when periodEnd
is null (canceled/deleted subs), so future lapses no longer collapse
to one key and get suppressed. New test; suite 499.
- documented the dispatcher's once/min concurrency assumption.
POST /api/cron/notifications drains <=20 pending rows/min, sends via the
transport with the row id as Resend Idempotency-Key (overlap-safe),
marks sent or increments attempts (retryable -> stay pending, permanent
or budget-exhausted -> failed). Constant-time CRON_SECRET bearer check;
503 when unset. ~4.5/s spacing under Resend's 5/s limit. proxy.ts
whitelists /api/cron (no session; own shared secret). CRON_SECRET added
to .env.example.
invoice.paid -> dues_renewed; invoice.payment_failed -> dues_payment_
failed; transition to late (applySubscription) -> dues_lapsed. The
webhook only writes the outbox row (ignoreDuplicates on the
(space_id,dedupe_key) unique index) so a Stripe event replay is a no-op
and the money path stays send-free, fast, and retry-safe. Recipient +
space name resolved server-side; manage link from the request host.
proxy.ts auth-gates every non-public path and 307-redirects to /login.
The Stripe webhook is called without a session, so it was being
redirected; Stripe does not follow redirects, so every webhook delivery
would have failed. Add /api/stripe/webhook to PUBLIC_ROUTES (scoped to
the webhook path only) and correct the route/header comments that wrongly
claimed there was no auth middleware. Caught by smoke-testing the
deployed route (POST returned 307 instead of 400).
Independent audit (verified vs Stripe Basil 2025-03-31 changelog):
- P0: period end moved off the top-level Subscription -> read
sub.items.data[0].current_period_end (grace/lapse now actually fires;
was always null -> past_due members never went 'late').
- P0: invoice subscription metadata moved under invoice.parent.
subscription_details -> read parent (metadata member-resolution was
always failing, mislinking dues payments).
- P1: handle only invoice.paid (not also invoice.payment_succeeded) +
pre-insert dedupe on (space_id,platform,external_id) -> no double
payment-ledger rows.
- P2: idempotencyKey on customers.create -> no duplicate Stripe
customers under concurrent checkout.
- 040: documented the 'do not wrap in manual BEGIN/COMMIT' caveat.
(P0 webhook-reprocess-on-failure was fixed in ca34e53.) Audit verdict:
isolation/secrets/RLS/status-bounds were already sound.
Self-audit finding: the idempotency row is written before processing,
so a handler exception/500 followed by Stripe's retry would be
suppressed as a duplicate and the event silently dropped. On the error
path, delete the dedupe row so the retry reprocesses. (Bad-signature/
config 400s and the non-unique insert-error 500 never wrote the row, so
those were already clean.)
app/api/stripe/webhook/[space]/route.ts (nodejs, force-dynamic). Raw
req.text() body; loads THIS space's secret + signing secret from the
vault; constructEvent verifies signature; idempotency via the
stripe_webhook_events PK (replay -> 200). Handles checkout.session.
completed / customer.subscription.* / invoice.paid|payment_succeeded:
upserts member_billing, records a stripe payments row, and maps status
via duesMemberStatus+graceExceeded onto space_members (only current<->
late, never resurrect inactive / auto-approve unverified; last_paid_at
on paid). Member resolved by metadata then customer-id, always
space-scoped. Bad sig/config -> 400; handler error -> 500 (Stripe
retries, idempotency-safe).
PayPal sync route now returns the inserted rows; the client prepends
them (mirrors handleLogCash) instead of window.location.reload(),
preserving scroll/filter state. Was the only full reload in the app.
payments has no unique index on external_id, so the
onConflict:'external_id' upsert was unreliable and fell back to an
insert that stripped external_id -- creating duplicate, non-idempotent
rows on every re-sync, and not tenant-scoped. Now: look up which PayPal
transaction ids already exist in THIS space and insert only the new
rows (external_id preserved). No schema change.
Adds proposals + proposal_votes + policies + incidents + incident_updates
tables with full RLS, async voting flow, dismissal-appeal pathway,
versioned policies with provenance, and an anonymous-incident token mode.
Adds per-space configurable areas, financial visibility settings, member
self-profile + COI disclosure, and a mission statement that renders in
the app footer.
Reorganises lib/actions.ts into per-domain files (tasks, projects,
members, payments, contacts, knowledge-base, secrets, area-leads,
settings, imports, proposals, incidents, policies, areas) plus a barrel.
Adds lib/permissions.ts and lib/auth-helpers.ts so action bodies stop
duplicating the user-to-member-to-role check. Wires every action that has
a Zod schema; introduces a flexibleDateTime preprocessor so HTML date
pickers no longer hit "Invalid datetime".
Hardens RLS: drops NOT NULL on space_members.user_id for offline members,
adds a privilege-escalation trigger that blocks self-edits to role / tier
/ status / approved / has_card_access / space_id, closes four
cross-tenant holes in the governance kernel, and adds a partial unique
index so two admins cannot concurrently activate two drafts of the same
policy slug.
Ships every deployment artifact: Dockerfile, docker-compose,
.do/app.yaml, .env.example, /api/health, plus a managed-Supabase guide
(docs/DEPLOYMENT.md), an end-to-end self-hosted Droplet guide
(docs/DEPLOY_DO_SELFHOSTED.md), and a Supabase-CLI local-dev quickstart
(docs/LOCAL_DEV.md). Replaces middleware.ts with proxy.ts for Next.js 16.
Adds scripts/schema.sql as the canonical idempotent full deploy plus
fourteen numbered incremental migrations.
Adds scripts/seed.sql so a fresh local DB renders something instead of
empty pages: a demo space, five members across all roles, a v1 code of
conduct, three proposals in different states with seven votes already
cast, an open incident, a project, three tasks, a KB entry, and matching
activity-log rows.
Replaces v0-generated test scaffolding with 266 real tests across
__tests__/{actions,auth-helpers,components,governance,permissions,
security,utils,validations}.test.ts. Adds react-markdown + remark-gfm
for proposal / incident / policy body rendering. Deletes four dead v0
fix-* scripts, the unused components/app-shell.tsx, and the duplicate
app/auth/login/page.tsx.
Routes (31 total): /api/health, /api/paypal/sync, /auth/callback, /,
/login, /signup, /signup/confirm, /dashboard, /tasks, /projects,
/members, /payments, /financials, /contacts, /ops, /ops/[id], /ops/new,
/proposals, /proposals/[id], /proposals/new, /incidents, /incidents/[id],
/incidents/new, /policies, /policies/[slug], /policies/new, /profile,
/recruitment, /settings, /comms, /import.
Full pass-by-pass history is in docs/HANDOFF.md; the roadmap is in
docs/GOVERNANCE_FEATURES.md.
Moheeb Zara
v0andMoheeb Zara